Welcome to the Garden Ninja Gardening Forum! If you have a gardening question that you can't find answers to then ask below to seek help from the Garden Ninja army! Please make your garden questions as specific and detailed as possible so the community can provide comprehensive answers in the online forum below.

Welcome to the ultimate beginner gardening and garden design forum! Where no gardening question is too silly or obvious. This online gardening forum is run by Lee Burkhill, the Garden Ninja from BBC 1's Garden Rescue and a trusted group of experienced gardeners.

Whether you are a beginner or an expert gardener, it's a safe place to ask garden-related questions for garden design or planting. If you have a problem in your garden or need help, this is the Garden Forum for you!

Posting Rules: This space is open for all garden-related questions. Please be polite, courteous and respectful. If you wouldn't say it to your mum's face, then don't post it here. Please don't promote, sell, link spam or advertise here. Please don't ask for 'cheeky' full Garden redesigns here. They will be deleted.

If you need a garden design service, please use this page to book a design consultation. I will block anyone who breaks these rules or is discourteous to the Garden Ninja Community.

Join the forum below with your gardening questions!

Ask a Gardening QuestionBeginner Gardening Questions & Guides: First time gardener questionsFake Grass pros and Cons - Should …

Please or Register to create posts and topics.

Fake Grass pros and Cons - Should I use it for low maintenance gardening?

#1 · 19th October 2021, 8:29 am

Hi Garden Ninja,

I've recently moved house during lockdown and now have my very first garden! Eeek. Brilliant but I have no idea where to start. It's only small and in part shade for some of the day. Most of it is lawn which I quite like but not sure I have the time to maintain the lawn with my work.

My friends had fake grass fitted this year and he's raved about it. Though it seems really expensive. Wondering what your thoughts are. I'd like to create a gorgeous garden just thinking with flower beds I may not have time for the lawn?

I've got a dog and and thought it would be somewhere a bit cleaner for him to run?

Am I barking mad?

Thoughts?!

Sam

#2 · 20th October 2021, 10:38 am

Quote from Lee Garden Ninja on 20th October 2021, 10:38 am
Hi Sam,
Thanks for your question about artificial grass and whether you should choose it as a low maintenance option in your garden.
I've written extensively on the pros and cons of fake grass which you can read here. To get to the point I would never advocate the use of fake or artificial grass in any garden after experiencing the cons first-hand in peoples gardens. I never fit it or design with it. Before we start it's important to note that artificial grass or astroturf is not recyclable so at the end of its life it has to currently go to a landfill. This is what the artificial and fake turf companies don't want you to know. See the environmental nightmare below at a waste site in Europe for fake grass.
The problem with artificial or fake grass is that it's sold as a low maintenance option. Fake grass is not low maintenance.
Whilst you don't need to mow fake grass there are certain tasks that need to be undertaken to keep it in a useable condition. Let's have a look below at some of these fake grass maintenance tasks.
1. Raking/vacuuming fake grass: Artificial grass will let water through, albeit at a slower rate to real turf, however, any debris like leaves or soil gets stuck with nowhere to go. Meaning with fake grass you have to either rake, brush or even use an outdoor vacuum cleaner to remove this dirt. If not it just builds up causing a very messy patch of fake grass.
2. Removing dog or pet waste: Yes the biggest drawback with fake grass is if you have pets. Some people falsy believe its better for pets as the grass doesn't yellow with dog or cat wee. But if soil and leaves need removing from fake grass what do you think needs to happen with dog poo or cat faeces. You've guessed it! You have to remove it before it gets trodden or worn into the plastic matting.
Unlike real turf where dog mess can over time break down into the soil with fake grass it can't. I've seen some absolutely gross artificial lawns where dog poo has become worn into the plastic blades and matting leaving an unsightly and stinking lawn.
3. Brushing in sand each year: Another thing you need to do is brush in the sand to help disguise the gaps and matting that the blades of fake grass are woven through. This is to try and disguise the fact it's a plastic lawn. Even the best fake lawns still look unrealistic and some downright nuclear green! Any decent gardener can spot one a mile off! The below fake grass looks more like carpet than lawn turf!
4. Disinfecting problem stains and smells: If you've ended up with trapped waste, debris or smells in your fake grass then you then have either the option to lightly jet wash this crud elsewhere or use chemical disinfectant and scrub it manually. However, this is completely against organic gardening principles which we should be following. Adding these disinfectants in the garden plays havoc with soil health and will kill off all sorts of wildlife. It is scandalous that these fake grass cleaning sprays are even sold in garden centres.
Alternatives to fake grass:
Even with a shady garden, there are multiple options rather than this unrecyclable mess of fake grass. Gravel, chipped bark or even shady grass seed mixes are all preferable and far kinder to wildlife. Real grass is far less maintenance, drama and is much kinder to the environment. If you can't manage a real lawn, then a fake one is no better for you so think of another garden design option.
Look below at the sea of fake grass, it doesn't look real and has zero benefits to wildlife. This owner in my opinion would have been better with a low maintenance gravel garden instead.
Ask yourself the question do you even need a lawn or could you create something far more suitable for your maintenance level, like an evergreen shrub based garden that provides year-round interest maybe with a seating area and chipped bark path? Far more inviting than plastic grass covered in dog poo!
Try and think outside the box or get in touch with a garden designer to help you. There's always a better solution out there.
So bearing all that in mind fake grass really isn't a low maintenance option at all. I'd go as so far as to say it's mega maintenance.
Go forth, be bold and don't follow the plastic grass crowd!
Lee

Hi Sam,

Thanks for your question about artificial grass and whether you should choose it as a low maintenance option in your garden.

I've written extensively on the pros and cons of fake grass which you can read here. To get to the point I would never advocate the use of fake or artificial grass in any garden after experiencing the cons first-hand in peoples gardens. I never fit it or design with it. Before we start it's important to note that artificial grass or astroturf is not recyclable so at the end of its life it has to currently go to a landfill. This is what the artificial and fake turf companies don't want you to know. See the environmental nightmare below at a waste site in Europe for fake grass.

The problem with artificial or fake grass is that it's sold as a low maintenance option. Fake grass is not low maintenance.

Whilst you don't need to mow fake grass there are certain tasks that need to be undertaken to keep it in a useable condition. Let's have a look below at some of these fake grass maintenance tasks.

1. Raking/vacuuming fake grass: Artificial grass will let water through, albeit at a slower rate to real turf, however, any debris like leaves or soil gets stuck with nowhere to go. Meaning with fake grass you have to either rake, brush or even use an outdoor vacuum cleaner to remove this dirt. If not it just builds up causing a very messy patch of fake grass.

2. Removing dog or pet waste: Yes the biggest drawback with fake grass is if you have pets. Some people falsy believe its better for pets as the grass doesn't yellow with dog or cat wee. But if soil and leaves need removing from fake grass what do you think needs to happen with dog poo or cat faeces. You've guessed it! You have to remove it before it gets trodden or worn into the plastic matting.

Unlike real turf where dog mess can over time break down into the soil with fake grass it can't. I've seen some absolutely gross artificial lawns where dog poo has become worn into the plastic blades and matting leaving an unsightly and stinking lawn.

3. Brushing in sand each year: Another thing you need to do is brush in the sand to help disguise the gaps and matting that the blades of fake grass are woven through. This is to try and disguise the fact it's a plastic lawn. Even the best fake lawns still look unrealistic and some downright nuclear green! Any decent gardener can spot one a mile off! The below fake grass looks more like carpet than lawn turf!

4. Disinfecting problem stains and smells: If you've ended up with trapped waste, debris or smells in your fake grass then you then have either the option to lightly jet wash this crud elsewhere or use chemical disinfectant and scrub it manually. However, this is completely against organic gardening principles which we should be following. Adding these disinfectants in the garden plays havoc with soil health and will kill off all sorts of wildlife. It is scandalous that these fake grass cleaning sprays are even sold in garden centres.

Alternatives to fake grass:

Even with a shady garden, there are multiple options rather than this unrecyclable mess of fake grass. Gravel, chipped bark or even shady grass seed mixes are all preferable and far kinder to wildlife. Real grass is far less maintenance, drama and is much kinder to the environment. If you can't manage a real lawn, then a fake one is no better for you so think of another garden design option.

Look below at the sea of fake grass, it doesn't look real and has zero benefits to wildlife. This owner in my opinion would have been better with a low maintenance gravel garden instead.

Ask yourself the question do you even need a lawn or could you create something far more suitable for your maintenance level, like an evergreen shrub based garden that provides year-round interest maybe with a seating area and chipped bark path? Far more inviting than plastic grass covered in dog poo!

Try and think outside the box or get in touch with a garden designer to help you. There's always a better solution out there.

So bearing all that in mind fake grass really isn't a low maintenance option at all. I'd go as so far as to say it's mega maintenance.

Go forth, be bold and don't follow the plastic grass crowd!

Lee